The Risks of Tax Lien Investing: 6 Things Every Investor Should Know
Written By Tony Martinez
Main Points
Tax lien investing is often promoted as a “safe and guaranteed” way to earn high returns backed by real estate. While there are real opportunities, the truth is that this strategy carries risks many beginners overlook. Understanding these risks before you invest is the difference between building wealth and losing money.
Let’s break down the 6 major pitfalls you need to be aware of before you start investing in tax liens.
1. The Property Owner Redeems Too Quickly
When you purchase a tax lien certificate, you earn interest only for the time the lien is outstanding. If the property owner pays off the delinquent taxes in just a few weeks, your return may be minimal, sometimes not even enough to cover your initial fees.
This can be frustrating for new investors who expect big returns but end up with small profits or even a net loss.
For example, say you buy a lien for $1,000 at a 12% interest rate. Since the interest rate for tax lien certificates is annualized, the time at which the homeowner redeems will directly affect how much money you make.
If they redeem within the first month, you make 1% interest.
If they redeem at the end of the year, after 12 months, only then will you receive the full 12%.
While tax lien certificate investing is generally considered safe and secure, the timing of redemptions can impact your potential returns. It is also good to keep in mind that with tax lien certificate investing, the goal is to make money on interest, as it is not a property acquisition.
2. Poor Property Condition
Due diligence is everything in tax lien investing. Without proper research, you are essentially investing blind.
The property tied to the lien could be:
Abandoned
In severe disrepair
Contaminated or environmentally hazardous
Condemned by the city
Even though the primary goal of investing in tax lien certificates is to earn interest at high rates, you can’t overlook the risks tied to the underlying property itself.
If the owner fails to redeem, which could happen with an abandoned property, you could end up taking title. That means inheriting the property’s physical condition, for better or worse. A tax lien tied to a neglected, damaged, or even condemned property can quickly turn what seemed like a safe investment into a costly headache.
That’s why due diligence, such as researching the property’s condition, location, and market value, is just as important as calculating the potential interest return.
3. Overpaying at Auction
In hot markets, bidding wars are common. Some investors get caught up in the competition and overbid just to secure a lien. Unfortunately, paying too much can reduce or even wipe out your potential return.
A good way to avoid this is always to enter the auction knowing how much you are willing to pay for a lien.
Remember: if penalties and interest don’t cover your investment, you’ve locked up money for little to no gain. Smart investors always stick to pre-set bidding limits to avoid overspending.
4. Legal Complexity and Foreclosure Risk
If a lien isn’t paid off, you might have to go through foreclosure to take ownership. This doesn’t happen often, especially with primary homes, but when it does, the process can be slow and expensive. This usually includes things like:
Hiring attorneys
Covering court and filing fees
Waiting months (sometimes years) for the process to conclude
Foreclosure rules are state-specific and can be highly technical. Between legal fees, paperwork, and state-specific rules, foreclosure can take several months or even years, and sometimes it costs more than the property is worth.
5. State-by-State Differences
No two states are exactly alike when it comes to tax lien investing. Redemption periods, interest rates, penalties, and foreclosure rules vary dramatically depending on where you invest.
For example:
Florida: Tax lien certificates start at 18% annual interest, but the bidding method is a downward bid on the interest rate. Most liens redeem fairly quickly (often within a year), so while the rate is high on paper, the actual returns are usually lower.
Arizona: Tax liens are also bid down on interest, but the system and timelines differ. Arizona’s redemption period is 3 years, which is longer than Florida’s 2 years. That means investors may have to wait longer to see returns, but it also creates a longer window for possible foreclosure.
Assuming the rules are the same everywhere is a costly mistake. Always research the specific laws in the state (and even the county) where you plan to invest.
6. Liquidity Risk
Unlike stocks or mutual funds, tax liens aren’t easily bought and sold. Once your money is in a lien, it’s tied up until the property owner redeems or you foreclose.
There’s no guaranteed timeline. You could see your money back in weeks, or it could take years. For investors who need quick access to cash, this lack of liquidity is a major drawback.
So, with that said, for those investors who need fast access to cash or those hoping for steady passive income, this strategy may not be the right fit.
Why Education Is the Key to Tax Lien Investing Success
Tax lien investing can be profitable, but only for those who approach it with realistic expectations and careful preparation. While the idea of earning double-digit returns is appealing, the risks are very real.
By understanding these potential pitfalls, quick redemptions, poor property conditions, overbidding, legal hurdles, state differences, and liquidity challenges, you’ll be far better equipped to make smart, informed decisions.
If your ultimate goal is to acquire property at a fraction of its true value, tax lien and tax deed investing can open that door. But success doesn’t come from guesswork; it comes from knowing the rules, understanding the risks, and having a clear strategy. That’s exactly what we teach at USTLA.
With over 30 years of experience, we’ve helped thousands of investors learn how to turn tax liens and deeds into real opportunities, whether that means collecting interest income or gaining property for pennies on the dollar.
If you’re ready to start building your portfolio the smart way, enroll in our USTLA Free 3-Module Online Crash Course today and take the first step toward owning valuable real estate at low prices.
USTLA's FREE Comprehensive
3-Module Tax Lien Investment
Online Crash Crouse
The ultimate beginner's guide to successful tax lien
certificate & tax deed investing.
Start Learning from the Comfort of Your Home Today
Featured Lessons
Vital Information Beginner’s MUST KNOW FIRST so you can Get Started Right
Lesson #1
What is Tax Lien Investing & How Can it Help You Achieve Financial Freedom
Lesson #2
How to Acquire Properties for the Back Taxes & Penalties Only
Lesson #3
How Much Investment Capital is Needed to Get Started?
As with all investments, there is always an element of risk. Even if the interest rates are written into state government law, mandated by state government law, and are regulated by state government law, there is a chance of you losing part or all of your investment. You must always try to get the best education and practice safe investing, no matter which investment vehicle you choose.